|
Hmong
Courtship & Weddings - Alternate forms of Marriage
Overview
There are three basic paths to marriage: the formal marriage request the
groom's family; the voluntary elopement, and the bride abduction or
kidnapping. Most Hmong choose the first option because it brings the
most benefits such as joy, peace and happiness to both of families and
brings a sense of having fulfilled one’s communal responsibilities.
Sometimes, forced marriages are necessary if a young woman becomes
pregnant, which can result in difficult and delicate negotiations.
Voluntary elopement or bride abduction are typically not chosen as
marriage arrangements because most Hmong find these methods
inappropriate and disrespectful. Yet some still chose these paths
because they cannot afford the Bride Price, or because there are
personal or family issues that make it difficult to get parents or
family members to accept a marriage relationship.
One of the great concerns about elopement and abduction is that often
the young women who embark on these alternative marriage path are either
under the legal marriage age—many are still in high school—or are not
fully developed socially and emotionally. (For an interesting
perspective, see http://minnesota.publicradio.org/display/web/2006/03/20/hmongmarriage/)
Polygamy are also practiced, but remains controversial within many Hmong
families who reject the practice, particularly since arriving in the
United States. Also controversial, though not common in the United
States, is the practice of levirate, or compulsory marriage of a widow
to her deceased husband’s younger brother.
Forced Marriage
Some situations may force a Hmong man and woman to get married and
therefore change the dynamics of the traditional Bride Price negotiation
and potentially impact family and clan relations. For example, if the
woman gets pregnant during the courtship, and her family discovers the
pregnancy, the bride’s family generally (but not always) takes the
initiative to approach the groom’s family with this knowledge and demand
a marriage negotiation immediately. Upon proof of the pregnancy, the
groom’s family will likely acquiesce, even if requires a higher Bride
Price to compensate for the perceived bad behavior of the groom. If the
groom’s family does not acquiesce, the risks are great: losing a
relationship with a potential family heir.
Even if the family agrees to marriage, the wedding and the subsequent
family relationship could be damaged by bitterness, thus jeopardizing
future clan relationships. Nevertheless, in this scenario, the groom’s
family, especially parents, older married brothers, and male relatives
would likely do everything in their own power to convince the groom to
accept marriage. From the view of his family and clan, even a “shotgun”
marriage would be better socially and emotionally for the groom and his
family. His willing acceptance might also prevent unnecessary
deterioration of relations
between the families and clans.
Voluntary Elopement
Parents’ refusal or disagreement to allow their daughters to marry the
men of their choice does occur in Hmong American households on occasion.
If a courting couple wishes to get married, but the girl’s parents will
not accept her nuptial choice, she may choose to elope with her future
husband and move into his parents’ home. Also, some young women threaten
this path to escape pressure from parents or family to marry men that
they dislike.
Most Hmong parents understand the importance of successful marriage and
value personal freedom of choice; thus, they generally do not force
their daughters to marry men whom they truly do not wish to marry. In
the minds of Hmong parents, forced marriages often result in unhappy
married lives and divorces later down the road.
But even elopement, while not preferred , is not so traumatic that a
good marriage and good family and clan relationships cannot emerge
afterwards. No matter the circumstances, after the elopement, the
groom’s parents must choose and dispatch two messengers to the bride’s
family to officially announce that she left voluntarily with the groom
to marry him. The announcement must also be clear that the groom wished
to marry the bride. Upon this announcement, the bride’s parents would
formally accept the marriage. At this point, the newly wedded couple
would be sequestered in the home of the groom’s family for three days.
On the third day, the groom’s family would then host a welcoming
ceremony for the groom’s extended family and clan. On the fourth day,
the groom’s male relatives and family representatives (mej koob) would
approach the bride’s parents and begin a formal marriage negotiation
over bride-price, dowry and the payment of the wedding ceremony.
Following a successful negotiation, the wedding ceremony would proceed
as in a normal marriage. The majority of voluntary elopements end in
successful marriage. Unfortunately, some circumstances preclude normal
marriage relationships whether because the girl is simply too young or
because the bride’s parents or male reltaives simply find the young man
objectionable.
Bride Abduction or Kidnapping
One alternative form of marriage still practiced in Hmong society is
bride abduction or kidnapping. This process involves the abduction of a
female by the prospective husband without her personal consent or her
family’s approval. The bride kidnapping typically takes place while the
girl is away from her home or alone by herself. To carry out the deed,
the prospective husband usually receives assistance or support from a
group of close male relatives or friends. Upon bringing the kidnapped
woman to his family’s home, the man’s parents are obligated to send two
messengers to inform her parents of the abduction and relay his
intention to marry her. When the girl’s parents receive the news, they
have two options. First, if they do not find the man or his family
suitable, they may go to the abductor’s family house and demand the
release of their daughter. Second, the family can accept the abduction
and the subsequent marriage. This is more likely if they learn that the
would-be husband is a good person and that the family is suitable.
As with a forced marriage due to pregnancy, the marriage negotiations
would intensify if a baby were involved and could lead to the souring of
family and clan relations. In extreme cases, the Hmong community may
direct a clan leader to act as a go-between to resolve the matter. And
as with voluntary elopement, a bride abduction can lead to a negotiated
marriage that, if acceptable to both families, would bar any future
bitterness or disputes, allowing the couple’s married life to proceed as
if it were conceived in the traditional manner.
|